Law4u - Made in India

How Does IBC Handle Inter-Creditor Disputes?

Answer By law4u team

In the insolvency resolution process under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), inter-creditor disputes can arise due to differences in the rights, priorities, and treatment of various creditors. These disputes may involve disagreements between secured and unsecured creditors, financial and operational creditors, or even among creditors within the same category. The IBC provides a framework to address such disputes and ensure that the resolution process proceeds smoothly.

Handling of Inter-Creditor Disputes Under IBC:

Role of the Committee of Creditors (CoC): The Committee of Creditors (CoC) plays a central role in addressing inter-creditor disputes. The CoC consists of the creditors who have submitted their claims and whose claims have been verified. The CoC:

  • Makes key decisions related to the resolution process, including approval of the resolution plan.
  • Has voting rights based on the proportion of the debt owed to each creditor. This voting mechanism can sometimes create disputes if creditors from different classes (e.g., secured vs. unsecured) have conflicting interests regarding the resolution plan.

Voting Mechanism: The IBC uses a voting mechanism to resolve disagreements within the CoC:

  • Simple Majority: Most decisions within the CoC, such as approving or rejecting a resolution plan, are taken by a simple majority (i.e., more than 50% of the voting shares of creditors).
  • 65% Voting Requirement: For specific decisions, such as approving the resolution plan, a 65% majority of the voting shares in the CoC is required. This could lead to inter-creditor disputes if there is a split vote between secured and unsecured creditors, or between creditors with varying priorities.

Priority of Claims: One of the main sources of inter-creditor disputes is the priority of claims. The IBC clearly defines the order in which creditors are paid:

  • Secured creditors typically have a higher priority over unsecured creditors.
  • If there are disputes over whether a creditor is classified as secured or unsecured, or the amount of security available to certain creditors, these disputes may need to be resolved through negotiations or judicial intervention by the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT).

Role of the Insolvency Resolution Professional (IRP): The Insolvency Resolution Professional (IRP) is responsible for managing the resolution process. The IRP ensures that all creditor claims are verified and that the CoC is functioning according to the rules. In cases of inter-creditor disputes, the IRP may mediate and facilitate discussions between creditors to achieve a consensus or to ensure compliance with the IBC.

Judicial Intervention by NCLT: In case of persistent inter-creditor disputes that cannot be resolved within the CoC or during the resolution process, creditors can approach the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT). The NCLT can provide clarity on legal issues, such as the eligibility of creditors to vote, the validity of claims, or the priority of debt, ensuring a fair and transparent resolution process.

Settlement and Mediation: In certain cases, the IBC encourages settlement and mediation to resolve inter-creditor disputes. The creditors can reach a mutual agreement on the terms of the resolution plan through negotiation. The Resolution Professional (RP) often facilitates discussions between creditors to find a middle ground and avoid litigation.

Cross-Class and Cross-Border Disputes: When the inter-creditor dispute involves different classes of creditors or creditors from multiple jurisdictions, the IBC allows for cross-class settlement. The Cross-Border Insolvency Regulations (if applicable) provide a framework to handle disputes involving foreign creditors and assets.

Legal Actions and Protections:

Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC): The IBC provides the legal foundation for the treatment of inter-creditor disputes by:

  • Ensuring a transparent and structured process for creditor claims.
  • Enforcing the priority of claims and providing a clear order of payment.
  • Granting the CoC the power to make decisions, but with safeguards for minority creditors.

Judicial Oversight: The NCLT and NCLAT provide judicial oversight over disputes, ensuring that the process is fair and that creditor rights are protected. If creditors disagree with the CoC’s decisions, they may appeal the decisions to the NCLAT.

Inter-Creditor Agreement (ICA): In some cases, creditors may enter into an Inter-Creditor Agreement (ICA), which outlines how they will cooperate during the resolution process. This can help mitigate inter-creditor disputes by setting clear expectations regarding decision-making processes and the allocation of recoveries.

Example:

In the insolvency of a manufacturing company, a secured lender (e.g., a bank with collateral) and an unsecured operational creditor (e.g., a supplier) may have conflicting views on the resolution plan:

  • The secured lender may demand a higher share of the assets since it holds security over the company’s assets.
  • The operational creditor may argue that the secured creditor has already been adequately compensated and that it should receive a higher proportion of the resolution plan's recovery due to the nature of its claim.
  • The IRP and CoC will attempt to mediate and facilitate a compromise. If the dispute cannot be resolved, the NCLT may step in to provide clarity on the matter, ensuring that the insolvency process continues in an orderly and fair manner.

Our Verified Advocates

Get expert legal advice instantly.

Advocate Anshuman Pandey

Advocate Anshuman Pandey

Anticipatory Bail, Breach of Contract, Cheque Bounce, Civil, Court Marriage, Criminal, Divorce, Documentation, Domestic Violence, Family, Landlord & Tenant, Property, R.T.I, RERA, Revenue, Arbitration, Banking & Finance, Cyber Crime, High Court, Media and Entertainment, Motor Accident, Muslim Law, Succession Certificate

Get Advice
Advocate Hitesh Vekariya

Advocate Hitesh Vekariya

Cyber Crime, Criminal, Civil, Banking & Finance, Customs & Central Excise

Get Advice
Advocate Anand K C

Advocate Anand K C

Anticipatory Bail, Cheque Bounce, Criminal, Motor Accident, R.T.I

Get Advice
Advocate Sagar Verma

Advocate Sagar Verma

Anticipatory Bail, Cheque Bounce, Child Custody, Civil, Consumer Court, Court Marriage, Cyber Crime, Divorce, Domestic Violence, Family, High Court, Insurance, Muslim Law, Property, R.T.I, Recovery, Supreme Court, Tax

Get Advice
Advocate Ambrish Dwivedi

Advocate Ambrish Dwivedi

Cheque Bounce,Civil,Criminal,Documentation,GST,Domestic Violence,High Court,Labour & Service,Landlord & Tenant,Revenue

Get Advice
Advocate Ashutosh Tripathi

Advocate Ashutosh Tripathi

Criminal, Cyber Crime, Labour & Service, Motor Accident, Insurance

Get Advice
Advocate Jagannath Kumar

Advocate Jagannath Kumar

Civil, Criminal, Cyber Crime, Property, Wills Trusts, Anticipatory Bail

Get Advice
Advocate Nilesh Kumar

Advocate Nilesh Kumar

Cheque Bounce, Criminal, Property, Motor Accident, Family

Get Advice

Corporate and Business Law Related Questions

Discover clear and detailed answers to common questions about Corporate and Business Law. Learn about procedures and more in straightforward language.