- 01-May-2025
- Personal Injury Law
Workers' compensation is designed to provide financial support to employees who suffer job-related injuries or illnesses. However, there are instances where a claim may be disputed, and the injured worker may wish to contest the outcome. While most workers' compensation claims are handled through administrative processes, workers do have options to contest the claim's decision in court under certain circumstances.
If there is a disagreement between the injured worker and the insurance company or employer regarding the validity of the claim, the benefits awarded, or the extent of the injury, the worker may contest the decision in court.
When a workers' compensation claim is denied, the worker can challenge the decision. This often occurs when the insurer believes the injury is not work-related or insufficient evidence is provided to support the claim.
In most cases, workers' compensation disputes are initially resolved through administrative hearings conducted by a workers' compensation board or commission. However, if a party is dissatisfied with the ruling, they may be able to appeal the decision to a higher court for judicial review.
If a worker believes that the awarded compensation (e.g., wage replacement, medical treatment) is too low or inadequate, they may choose to contest the amount in court.
In rare cases, workers may allege fraud or misconduct by the employer or insurance company, and they may contest the workers' compensation claim in court as part of a broader legal action.
Before going to court, workers typically must first go through an administrative hearing process where the workers' compensation board or commission reviews the claim. If the decision is unfavorable, workers can then appeal the decision to a higher authority.
If the administrative body denies the claim or rules in favor of the employer or insurance company, the worker can file an appeal with an appellate court or higher administrative tribunal. The appeal must generally be filed within a certain period after the initial ruling (typically 30-60 days).
If the appeal at the administrative level is unsuccessful, the worker can request a judicial review of the case in a civil court. Judicial review is not a re-hearing of the facts but a legal review of the administrative decision to ensure it was made properly and in accordance with the law.
In court, the burden of proof may shift slightly, and the worker will need to present a strong case with evidence (e.g., medical records, expert testimony, witness statements). The court will evaluate whether the workers' compensation board made an error in its decision or application of the law.
One of the most common reasons workers contest a claim is if the insurer or employer argues that the injury was not work-related. Workers can challenge this by providing medical evidence or witness testimony to demonstrate that the injury occurred at work or was caused by their job.
Workers may contest the amount of compensation they receive. For example, if a worker believes that the disability rating assigned to their injury is too low or that their lost wages are not fully covered, they can contest this in court.
Workers can contest a denial of medical treatment. If an insurance company refuses to cover necessary medical procedures or medications related to the injury, workers may seek a court's intervention to order the insurer to cover the costs.
If a worker suspects fraud (e.g., the employer or insurer intentionally falsified records or misrepresented facts), they can pursue legal action in court.
If the case goes to court, the judge or jury will review the facts of the case, consider any new evidence presented, and issue a decision. The court may uphold, modify, or reverse the workers' compensation board’s decision.
In some jurisdictions, either party (the worker or the employer) can appeal the court's decision to a higher court. This process may continue until the case is resolved at the highest legal level.
Contesting a workers' compensation claim may lead to a delay in receiving benefits while the case is being reviewed or litigated in court. Workers may need to manage financially without the compensation they are seeking.
Workers who contest their claim in court may incur significant legal costs. However, in some cases, the employer may be required to pay the worker’s legal fees if the worker prevails in the case.
Workers typically contest a workers' compensation decision because they believe the injury is being minimized, benefits are insufficient, or the process was handled incorrectly.
Contesting the claim may also be necessary if there is evidence of misconduct by the employer or insurance company, or if the employer is trying to prevent the worker from receiving the benefits they are entitled to.
Sarah, a factory worker, injures her hand while operating machinery. Her workers' compensation claim is approved, but she is dissatisfied with the compensation she is receiving, as it is insufficient to cover her medical expenses and lost wages. Sarah believes that the insurance company is undervaluing her injury and the impact it has on her ability to work.
Sarah initially appeals the decision through the workers' compensation board, presenting medical evidence to show the severity of her injury.
The board rules in favor of the insurance company, but Sarah believes the decision was incorrect. She files an appeal with the local court, requesting a judicial review of the board’s decision.
After a hearing, the court rules that the board did not properly evaluate Sarah’s injury and orders the insurance company to provide additional compensation for her medical treatment and lost wages.
Workers' compensation claims can be contested in court, primarily if the worker disagrees with the outcome of the administrative hearing, such as a claim being denied or compensation being insufficient. The process typically involves filing an appeal, presenting evidence, and requesting judicial review. Workers have the right to challenge unfavorable decisions and seek legal remedies if they believe they are not receiving the compensation they deserve. Understanding the appeals process and seeking legal representation can significantly increase the chances of a successful outcome.
Answer By Law4u Team
Discover clear and detailed answers to common questions about Personal Injury Law. Learn about procedures and more in straightforward language.
