Artificial islands are man-made structures created in the ocean or seas, often for purposes such as resource extraction, military use, or tourism. Under international maritime law, particularly the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), the legal status of artificial islands is complex and varies depending on their location and use. These structures do not have the same legal status as naturally occurring islands and do not generate their own territorial waters or Exclusive Economic Zones (EEZ). Instead, their legal status is governed by a set of specific rules that take into account the rights of coastal states and the need for the protection of marine environments.
According to UNCLOS Article 60, artificial islands and installations do not have the same status as natural islands and do not have territorial waters. They are considered artificial and do not generate a territorial sea or an Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ). These structures can, however, be constructed in a coastal state's EEZ with the consent of the state. If the artificial island is built in international waters (the high seas), it does not generate any maritime zones either.
Artificial islands are not entitled to territorial waters or a continental shelf under international law. The creation of such islands does not confer any rights of sovereignty over the adjacent waters. For example, even if an artificial island is constructed in the EEZ of a coastal state, the state’s sovereignty over the waters does not extend to the island itself.
In the EEZ of a coastal state, artificial islands may be constructed, but they are subject to the jurisdiction of the coastal state for purposes such as safety, navigation, and environmental protection. However, the rights of other states to conduct activities such as fishing or navigation remain unaffected by the presence of artificial islands unless specific regulations are established by the coastal state.
UNCLOS emphasizes the protection and preservation of the marine environment. The construction of artificial islands should not result in significant harm to marine ecosystems. The coastal state must ensure that any such activities comply with international environmental standards and principles, including conducting environmental impact assessments.
The presence of an artificial island does not restrict the freedom of navigation in the surrounding waters, particularly in areas like the high seas or international waters. Ships and aircraft have the right to pass through these waters unless otherwise restricted for safety or environmental protection purposes as determined by the coastal state.
If an artificial island is located in a coastal state's EEZ, the state has jurisdiction over the construction, maintenance, and operation of the island. It has the right to regulate its use for purposes such as resource exploitation (e.g., oil or gas) and can enforce laws related to safety and environmental concerns.
If an artificial island is built in the high seas, outside the jurisdiction of any coastal state, it does not generate any sovereign rights or maritime zones, and it remains subject to international law, especially regulations regarding environmental impact and freedom of navigation.
Artificial islands do not affect the delimitation of maritime zones. The zones of territorial sea, EEZ, and continental shelf of a coastal state are not extended by the construction of artificial islands. In the high seas, no additional maritime zones are created by the presence of artificial islands.
Consider a scenario where a coastal state builds an artificial island within its EEZ for the purpose of conducting oil drilling operations. The legal implications would be as follows:
The coastal state would have full jurisdiction over the artificial island, including the right to regulate its use, manage its construction, and ensure compliance with environmental regulations.
The artificial island would not generate its own territorial sea, so the area around the island would remain part of the EEZ, with no new territorial waters being created.
Other nations' ships and aircraft retain the right to freely navigate through the surrounding waters, provided they do not interfere with the legitimate use of the artificial island, such as resource extraction or environmental protection measures.
The coastal state would be responsible for ensuring that the construction and operation of the artificial island do not harm marine ecosystems. An environmental impact assessment (EIA) would be required to assess and mitigate any potential risks.
If artificial islands are built in areas where maritime boundaries are disputed, they may lead to conflicts between countries, especially if the island construction affects the claimed boundaries of EEZs or territorial seas. Such disputes can complicate the legal status of the artificial islands.
The creation of artificial islands can disrupt marine ecosystems, especially if construction involves dredging or altering coastlines. Strict international regulations are required to prevent or mitigate environmental degradation from such projects.
While UNCLOS provides a framework for the regulation of artificial islands, there is a need for greater international cooperation to address issues like environmental protection, safety, and freedom of navigation. This can be particularly challenging when artificial islands are built in sensitive or ecologically important areas.
The legal status of artificial islands under UNCLOS is clear in that these structures do not have the same rights as natural islands and do not generate their own territorial waters or maritime zones. Coastal states have jurisdiction over artificial islands in their EEZ, but this is limited to regulating their use and protecting the marine environment. International cooperation and careful consideration of environmental impacts are essential to ensuring that artificial islands are developed in a sustainable and legally compliant manner.
Answer By Law4u Team
Discover clear and detailed answers to common questions about public international law. Learn about procedures and more in straightforward language.
